Ballon d'Or 2024: A Ceremony of Surprises

Share

Ballon d'Or

This year’s Ballon d'Or sparked more debate than usual, with Rodri taking home the coveted prize over favorites like Vinicius Jr. While fans often disagree on who should win, 2024’s result raised new questions around the selection criteria, player roles, fair play, and even some behind-the-scenes drama. Let's dive into the major talking points: 1. The Criteria and Scoring System The Ballon d'Or’s decision-making process is based on three key criteria: individual performance and character, team achievements, and sportsmanship. Rodri’s win clearly aligns with these priorities; his role in Manchester City’s treble season underscored his importance to one of the most dominant teams in recent football history. On the other hand, Vinicius Jr. brought excitement and creativity, leading Real Madrid's frontline with notable flair. The debate here: which is more valuable—consistent brilliance or game-changing talent? 2. Fan-Favorite vs. Jury Choice For weeks, media speculation pointed to Vinicius Jr. as a likely winner, amplifying fan disappointment when Rodri’s name was called. The Ballon d'Or jury, comprised of journalists from the top 100 FIFA-ranked countries, chose a steady performer over an electrifying crowd-puller. Vinicius Jr.’s supporters argue that his direct, aggressive style has more “wow factor” than Rodri’s disciplined midfield play. However, the jury’s decision suggests a preference for steady excellence over highlight-reel moments. 3. Fair Play: Should it Matter? One of the more divisive topics is whether player conduct should factor into the award. Rodri is known for his calm and disciplined style, while Vinicius Jr. has, at times, faced criticism for confrontations on the field. While this may seem minor, it reflects a broader question: does a player’s behavior impact their legacy, and should it influence awards? This discussion could shape the values that top honors like the Ballon d'Or prioritize in years to come. 4. The Rise of the Midfielder: A Shift in the Award's Focus? Historically, forwards dominate the Ballon d'Or, celebrated for goals and assists. Rodri’s win, however, could signal a shift in how the football community values other roles, especially the workhorse midfielders who set the tempo and shape play from deeper positions. In his acceptance speech, Rodri even paid homage to past overlooked midfield maestros like Iniesta, Xavi and Busquets. Could this represent a new appreciation for the “invisible” work that underpins every successful team? 5. Real Madrid’s Absence Perhaps one of the evening’s biggest surprises was Real Madrid’s absence from the ceremony, an unusual move for a club awarded “Club of the Year.” Some speculate this was due to their discontent over the award results, while others see it as a larger statement on how these awards are managed. Whatever the reason, it has added an intriguing layer to this year’s event, leading fans to wonder what politics might lie beneath these public ceremonies. Rodri’s win opens up an important dialogue about what we value in players today. Does the Ballon d'Or need to shift towards rewarding more visibly exciting players, or does Rodri’s win signal a deeper appreciation for those who work quietly in pivotal roles?


P.S. For 2 months, the ScoutDecision team collected testimonials from scouts in our network about their jobs, the tools they use, etc. Now you can read the results for free here: Football Scouting Survey 2024

ScoutDecision Logo 9

ScoutDecision Communities

Want to link to other Scouts, Analysts, Coaches or Agents?

Join our WhatsApp channel to chat about ideas and opportunities!